Independent practice · about 20–30 minutes

Checkpoint 2 · Asking at the library

Read Rowan’s story and work through the tasks in order. Draft your reasoning before reading each suggested response. More than one approach may fit.

Writing is optional. Drafts stay on this page until you reload or leave it. Download any draft you want to keep.

The fictional situation

Rowan wants to ask a librarian whether a beginner book group is suitable. They predict, “The librarian will laugh or say my question is stupid.” Rowan usually asks a friend to speak for them. The library is an ordinary setting they have safely visited before.

Practice tasks

1. Design the experiment

Write the question Rowan could choose to ask. What words or actions would count as ridicule? What support needs to stay in place?

Suggested response for task 1

Rowan could choose to ask one clear suitability question. Observe words and actions, not hidden opinions. Preserve any communication accommodations; consider voluntarily changing only the friend speaking on their behalf if that fits Rowan’s needs.

2. Interpret a brief response

The librarian says, “Yes, beginners are welcome,” then turns to another visitor. Did the predicted ridicule occur? What can Rowan conclude about the visit, and what is still unknown?

Suggested response for task 2

The predicted explicit ridicule did not occur in this trial. A brief answer does not establish a private opinion. Rowan obtained information while possibly still anxious.

3. Interpret an awkward response

Now imagine the librarian says, “It is on the sign.” Compare those words with Rowan’s prediction of laughter or an insult. What would you conclude from this version, and what could Rowan do next?

Suggested response for task 3

This may be unhelpful or brusque, but it is not identical to explicit ridicule. Note the exact response, consider its limits, and decide whether another source of information or a different next step is useful.

Review your first draft

Find one place your draft meets these criteria and one place you would revise. This is a self-check.

Return to the chapters