Chapter 1 of 12
Why we misinterpret people
Written edition. The audiobook has an earlier version of this page.
On this page
We see what someone does, then try to explain why. Mistakes happen when we treat a guess as a fact, overlook conflicting information, or judge the person without considering their circumstances.
This chapter explains those mistakes and how to check them. The short examples below are fictional.
One habit to practise
When you feel sure why someone acted, pause and ask:
- What did they say or do?
- Why do I think they did it?
- How could I check?
Observation and interpretation
An observation describes what you saw or heard. An interpretation is the meaning or explanation you give it.
Example: “My friend hasn't replied for two days” describes what happened. “They don't care about me” is an interpretation.
Use it: Write the action and your explanation separately. This makes the explanation easier to question.
Limit: An interpretation can be right. Separating it from the observation means you can check it. Your feelings matter too: feeling hurt describes your experience, but does not establish the other person's intention.
Confirmation bias
Definition
- Confirmation bias
-
Looking for information—or understanding it in a way—that supports what you already believe.
Example: You think a colleague dislikes your ideas. You notice each criticism but overlook their positive comments, making your belief seem better supported. You may not realise you are doing it.
Use it: Ask, “What have I noticed that doesn't fit my explanation?” Look for an actual exception, rather than inventing a reassuring possibility.
Limit: Noticing this bias does not prove your conclusion is wrong. It gives you a reason to examine the information you used.
Evidence: Psychologist Raymond Nickerson's 1998 review examined this pattern across earlier studies of reasoning. It cannot decide whether a particular colleague dislikes your ideas.
Go deeper: Why confirmation bias happens, how to recognise it, and how to practise checking it. Includes a saved practice route in the app.
Correspondence bias
Definition
- Correspondence bias
-
Deciding that someone’s behaviour shows what they are like as a person, while giving too little weight to the situation they were in.
Example: A colleague gives a short reply. You decide they are rude without considering that they are facing an urgent deadline. You have judged their character while overlooking a possible situational explanation.
Use it: Ask, “Does this happen across situations, or mainly under particular conditions?” Compare ordinary occasions and exceptions.
Limit: Circumstances do not explain everything or excuse harmful behaviour. A repeated pattern still matters.
Evidence: Gilbert and Malone's 1995 review examined research on this bias. Confirmation bias concerns how you handle information; correspondence bias concerns how you explain behaviour.
Go deeper: Why we overlook circumstances, how to check a character judgment, and what can change. Includes a saved practice route in the app.
Check competing explanations
Consider a different explanation, including a misunderstanding of your own. Then look for information that could distinguish the possibilities.
Example: A client delays a purchase. You suspect they are losing interest; they say the budget is awaiting approval. Asking when the decision is expected and comparing that answer with later events is more useful than treating the delay itself as proof of either explanation.
Use it: Ask a specific question that lets the person explain, rather than assuming the motive: “What still needs deciding?”
Limit: An answer is information to assess, not automatic proof. Several reasons may apply. You may learn enough to act without settling every motive.
Respond while some things remain uncertain
You can make a request or set a limit based on what happened and how it affects you.
Example: “If the conversation turns into insults, I will end the call.” You do not need to establish why the person insults you before setting that limit.
Use it: Choose an action within your control, then review what happens. If asking directly could expose you to harm, consider a safer source of support.
More evidence and its limits
In two experiments published in 1984, Lord, Lepper and Preston found that considering an opposing explanation reduced the particular judgment errors studied. This supports checking alternatives; it does not validate every exercise in this book.
Malle's 2006 analysis of 173 studies did not support a general rule that we explain others through character and ourselves through circumstances. Results depended on the situation.
Henrich, Heine and Norenzayan's 2010 review questioned generalisations based mainly on wealthy Western populations. Consider local expectations without assuming someone's nationality explains their actions.
Key takeaways
- Keep what happened separate from your explanation.
- Look for conflicting information and relevant circumstances.
- Check what you can, then choose a response you can review.
Put it into practice
Recall
Try to recall the three questions from One habit to practise before opening the answer.
Show the three questions
- What did they say or do?
- Why do I think they did it?
- How could I check?
Try it
A separate fictional example: Your sister says your suggested outing sounds expensive. You think, “She never wants to spend time with me.”
What is known, what is guessed, and what would help you check? Answer before opening the example.
Show an example answer
You know she raised the cost. You are guessing she wants to avoid you. Ask which cost concerns her; compare occasions when she accepted an invitation. Her answer and those exceptions may change your explanation, without settling everything about the relationship.
Use it this week
Choose one ordinary situation and use the three questions. If you want to save your answers in this browser, open My practice notes below. Write what happened and your first explanation. After a useful, safe check, record what you learned and what you will do next.
My practice notes: Try the three questions
Notes save automatically in this browser when storage is available. Avoid names and sensitive details, especially on a shared browser. Download a text copy before clearing your browser data.
For a longer worked example, see Declining help.
Earlier practice notes
Your previous notes remain available here.
My practice notes: Notice confirmation bias
Notes save automatically in this browser when storage is available. Avoid names and sensitive details, especially on a shared browser. Download a text copy before clearing your browser data.
My practice notes: Notice correspondence bias
Notes save automatically in this browser when storage is available. Avoid names and sensitive details, especially on a shared browser. Download a text copy before clearing your browser data.
Go deeper in the reference library
- Names, respect & belonging — How names and titles can express familiarity, belonging or rank, and what a naming difference does not establish.
- Assumptions in questions & decision rights — Separate what a question asks from what it assumes, and a proposal from a decision someone is entitled to make.
- Different standards & unequal treatment — Compare favouritism and double standards with differences that reflect needs, responsibilities or prior agreements.
- Pressure, withdrawal & interaction cycles — Understand repeated sequences in which each person’s response changes what happens next.
- Personality facets & situation differences — Use narrower trait distinctions while avoiding character judgments from a few incidents.
- Exclusion, gossip & reputation — Distinguish being excluded from restriction of your contacts, and check how stories about people are transmitted.
- Compare occasions & test an explanation — Investigate recurrence, exceptions and competing explanations through proportionate observation, action and review.
- Use AI without reinforcing a first impression — Use an LLM to organise questions and alternatives while keeping generated suggestions separate from observations.
- Denial, attack & blame reversal — Recognise a sequence that redirects accountability while distinguishing it from legitimate defence or counter-complaint.
- Intense affection & inconsistent contact — Examine pace, consent, reliability and impact behind labels such as love bombing or breadcrumbing.
- Messages, tone & delayed replies — Interpret short or unanswered messages with attention to wording, medium, expectations and missing information.